Tag Archives: medicalization

That’s nuts.

This is intended to be read after reading Alaryyk’s post below.

How anyone could fathom that pointing rifles at someone’s head with K9 units’ foaming mouths looming behind them could be in any way conducive to “mental health”?  One of the complaints that friends of Alaryyk had been making before this police intervention occurred was that he had been “acting paranoid”.  Subjecting someone who is in a paranoid state to these tactics seems to me to be nothing but torture, torture of the highest degree.  Had Alaryyk been paranoid to the extent that he did not act cooperatively with the police, would he have been shot or attacked by a dog?  Subjecting anyone to this treatment, not having done anything in violation of the law, would cause a serious case of “post-traumatic stress disorder”.  Who knows what effect it has on a daily basis in this city, on people that are struggling with “mental health issues”…

I am disgusted and ashamed by the way “mental health” is handled in the province of British Columbia.  In Manitoba, if a concerned friend or family member reaches out into the public sphere for assistance when they believe someone they care about is having a “mental health crisis”, a “mobile crisis unit” arrives – no police, just an ambulance-type vehicle, and psychiatric nurses who will sit down with said individual in the comfort of their home to have a conversation in order to determine if they should be taken to the “safe” environment of a hospital or other temporary residential facility where they can “chill out”, for lack of a better term.

I moved West under the naive belief that west coast politics and policies were, as they had been in the past, more in favour of the freedom of the individual.  Through these experiences with Alaryyk, watching the city being plastered with propaganda about what one is and is not allowed to do in public space, and the distinct lack of “academic freedom” that I encountered at my educational institution last fall, I have realized that this was a daydream that has proven to hold no basis in reality.

Now I have people advising me to “move East, as soon as possible!” to find a more liberated environment.  As I will be required to do so to complete my next degree, I will make my next move with a much more jaded mind.

As social space is colonized by authorities, and our minds are colonized by a dogmatic culture where “you better act ‘normal’, or else…” I wonder if I will ever find a place that I feel is deserving of the title “home”.

Ugh….is it all in my head?

The next month is going to be a tough one.  3 6000 word length papers to write, 2 major presentations, 3 smaller papers, 48 hours of research assistant work that is waaaay overdue…oh, and major surgery! :roll:  I will continue to blog as much as possible, and I will post most of that work here when it is finished, as, of course, it is all related to the Sociology of “Madness”.  Yet you may be seeing more video postings and less of my writing.  I’m actually quite excited about these projects, and excited and scared about the surgery…

Mainly scared because of the ridiculous thought that entered my brain the other day.  I had forgotten to take my Effexor, Lamictal, and Clonazepam (all of my meds) and it was 4:00pm.  No brain-zaps yet!  I should have been dancing in brain-zap free movement and celebration.  But I had been acting a little out of sorts.  I called Alaryyk, who had just left to run some errands, and eagerly explained that any annoying behaviour I had enacted over the past few hours – I was feeling kind of weirdly insecure and I had been second guessing my thoughts, and thus the conversation we had before he left – could be blamed on this slip-up.  He assured me that I hadn’t been acting strange – and no brain-zaps?!  A good sign regarding the permanent brain damage I suspect Effexor has done.

Then a really DUMB thought entered my head – what if my pain is all in my head?  What if they do this surgery and find nothing floating around in my abdomen that shouldn’t be there?  What the hell would I do then, because I am in a lot of pain?

Etc, etc, etc.  This makes no “logical”, “rational” sense.  I have had horrible cramps but barely any period at all since I was 15 – the classic mark of endometriosis.  I had an ovarian cyst a couple of years back that ruptured before my ultrasound (there was a 5 month waiting period).  Deep sex is painful in the exact spot where my surgeon pointed to on a diagram, when deciding whether or not to schedule me for surgery, and how many incisions will be required.  In addition, after I had the “procedure” mentioned in previous posts (see post: “The Medicalization of Everywoman”;) I started bleeding like a goddamn fountain for 10 days a month, accompanied by the worst pain I’ve ever experienced, and am in less pain, but severe pain, throughout the entire month.  Sitting upright for my 2, 4-hour seminars is almost unbearable.

But, “what if?”

I suppose this is something that us psychiatrized individuals will always have to ponder when any other serious medical condition arises, especially a somewhat ambiguous one – not much is known about the cause of endometriosis, and many women go years and years without being diagnosed.  I should be considering myself lucky for the early-in-adulthood diagnosis.  I wrote a couple of days back about the host of new categories proposed for the DSM-V that medicalize “psychological conditions” affecting “other medical conditions”.  This is different.  It’s a constant self-questioning, self-doubting, that we “crazies” have to deal with, always, in a plethora of situations.

“Is this all in my head?!??!”

Did that conversation go so bad because I was being “irrational?”.  Did I get a poor mark on that assignment because I was “feeling kind of depressed when I wrote it, wasn’t I?  Was that the day?…”

Not to mention, “Did I lose my job because my coworkers started to think…??”

I am absolutely “out of the closet” as a crazy person, even more than I am about my bisexuality.  Since the scars on my arms are quite distinctive – can’t exactly be blamed on a car accident or animal attack – if I am not wearing long sleeves, I embody “madness”.  And I am proud of my scars and wear them like a badge, of trauma and survival.  Perhaps this makes it less likely for me to ever experience discrimination in my career, as there will never be any whispering around the water cooler of the type, “Do you think she’s bipolar or something?”.  There may be whispers of, “Have you seen her scars?”, but academia is quite a welcoming environment for those of us that don’t fit “normal”.  And my “madness” will always be right there on the table.

All of us who choose this career are a little strange – why would you go to school for 10+ years to obtain a Ph.D. when it won’t even guarantee you a job at the end of the “rainbow”?  (And it’s no rainbow ;) )  It is often, as Alaryyk and I have agreed is true for us, a career that chooses one more than one chooses it.  Neither of us could stand the monotony of a 9-5, never mind the fact that many a “mental health day” would be taken off.  I put in my time, working retail for 5 years when I was younger, and I left telling my boss that, “It is best for my coworkers and customers that I stop working here now.”  I certainly was not incompetent – I was the highest paid cashier/”customer satisfaction expert”, or whatever the latest job title that the corporation behind the Canadian chain Chapters/Indigo had come up with for us below-management little workers.  I sold more “Chapters Membership Cards” than anyone else.  You see, these sales had to account for 2% of all of a cashier’s sales at the end of the day.  Instead of receiving some kind of reward or commission – :lol: – we faced the possibility of being written up, and fired if we did not meet that goal.  I was the only person there that never had to worry about it.  But I was done with the general public’s demands on a lowly cashier, the mundane tasks assigned when it was not busy (dusting the shelves?  was that really part of my job description?  I don’t even dust my own shelves…;), and the times that I called in crying and had to drag myself to work an 8 hour shift in spite of whatever personal crisis I was having, as there was no one else scheduled and it was too late to call for a replacement.

I preferred “reading, writing, and talking”, which is basically the academic’s job description.  Furthermore we can work on our own schedule, except for teaching, which I’ve found to be a creative performance of sorts, and of course, a way to mould the minds of young adults into critical ones.  Self-doubt plagues all of us at times, but I have the support of my eccentric colleagues to talk about this with.  I’m not worried about making money, as long as I have enough to get by, I’m quite content.

But this other variety of self-doubt is new.  This thinking that somehow I have manifested this pain I’m constantly subject to.  That perhaps it is a reaction to past sexual abuse.  Perhaps it has something to do with deep worry about the problems my Mother had with her reproductive organs – she had 8 miscarriages before she gave birth to my little sister, which made for a really awesome childhood.  My own birth was a fluke of nature, as it was finally discovered that my mom had a rare antibody that attacked a fetus as if it was a foreign body, the same way one’s body can reject a transplanted organ.  Of course, it could be medicated.

This self-doubt and fear has nothing to do with the reactions of others – it’s not about what “they” think of me, but about what I am thinking, about what I am thinking about without thinking about it.  So until the moment I wake up in a hospital bed and am told about what the surgeon found inside of my pelvic region, I will wonder, “Is this all in my head?”

(Hilarious) Vintage Effexor XR Ad

One benefit of the fact that magazines in doctors’ offices are usually at least 5 years old is you get to look at old ads!  When I found this Effexor XR ad from the late-1990s, when it was still being marketed as an anti-anxiety medication, I had to have it.  Alaryyk and I posted it on the back of our bathroom door, so that guests could amuse themselves by taking the “Do you have excessive anxiety?” quiz while relieving themselves, but it wasn’t long before we defaced it, i.e. I answered the questions, and we filled out the “comments” section together.

The questions:

I had much difficulty answering number 6, as I do have trouble concentrating sometimes, but my mind never goes blank.  Then I realized the clauses were divided by the conjunction “or”.  Oh.

Answers:

Indeed, the instructions to add up the numbers and divide by 8 to get a “standardized score” included no information about what this “score” meant!

Comments:

Filling out that part was the most fun :D

MY ASS – Effexor has increased my anxiety like nobody’s business.  I guess that’s why it’s no longer marketed as an anti-anxiety pill.

DSM-IV-TR – your doctor has a copy, here’s one for you!

DSM IV TR

Here is a free copy of the latest edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders – the Bible of Psychiatry. Everyone should have a copy, just as almost every household had a copy of the Malleus Malificiarum (“The Witch’s Hammer) during the Dark Ages.  Even if you have never been diagnosed with a mental disorder, you can probably find a few “disorders” in here that describe you.

I was compelled to download this and post it for free after one of my seminars the other evening, when a peer brought up the following “disorder”.  Even I was shocked by this one:

302.3 Transvestic Fetishism

The paraphilic focus of Transvestic Fetishism involves cross-dressing by a male in women’s attire. In many or most cases, sexual arousal is produced by the accompa- nying thought or image of the person as a female (referred to as “autogynephilia”;).

These images can range from being a woman with female genitalia to that of a view of the self fully dressed as a woman with no real attention to genitalia. Women’s gar- ments are arousing primarily as symbols of the individual’s femininity, not as fetishes with specific objective properties (e.g., objects made of rubber).Usually the male with Transvestic Fetishism keeps a collection of female clothes that he intermittently uses to cross-dress. This disorder has been described only in heterosexual males. Trans- vestic Fetishism is not diagnosed when cross-dressing occurs exclusively during the course of Gender Identity Disorder. Transvestic phenomena range from occasional solitary wearing of female clothes to extensive involvement in a transvestic subcul- ture. Some males wear a single item of women’s apparel (e.g., underwear or hosiery) under their masculine attire. Other males with Transvestic Fetishism dress entirely as

females and wear makeup. The degree to which the cross-dressed individual success- fully appears to be a female varies, depending on mannerisms, body habitus, and cross-dressing skill. When not cross-dressed, the male with Transvestic Fetishism is usually unremarkably masculine. Although his basic preference is heterosexual, he

lends to have few sexual partners and may have engaged in occasional homosexual acts. An associa ted fea ture may be the presence of Sexual Masochism. The d isorder typically begins with cross-dressing in childhood or early adolescence. In many cases, the cross-dressing is not done in public until adulthood. The initial experience may involve partial or total cross-dressing; partial cross-dressing often progresses to com- pletecross-dressing. A favored article ofclothing may become erotic in itselfand may be used habitually, first in masturbation and later in intercourse. In some individuals, the motivation for cross-dressing may change over time, temporarily or permanently, with sexual arous., 1in response to the cross-dressing diminishing or disappearing. In such instances, the cross-dressing becomes an antidote to anxiety or depression.

DSM-V: “Mental Health” in 2013

Cheers to Lori for sending me this link to the latest information on the DSM-V from the APA.

A rude interruption to a relaxing Friday evening that I felt I must write something about immediately.

I had been concerned with the new “spectrum disorder” shift, regarding “mood” and “personality” disorders.  It’s in here – you no longer have to fit 5 of the listed criteria under the heading of a particular “disorder”.  You can now meet fewer of those characteristics and be diagnosed with a milder version of the condition of said disorder – medication being recommended in the vast majority of cases.  Earlier today I posted the current DSM (DSM-IV-TR) in its entirety :)  Look under the title of a personality disorder.  My favourite has always been “Borderline Personality Disorder”.  Read the criteria.  Almost any member of the general populace would, or should I say will, fit into one of the disease categories in the DSM if as few as 3 criteria are necessary for a diagnosis.

I however did not know about these proposed “disorders”:

316 Mental Disorder Affecting Medical Condition
316 Psychological Symptoms Affecting Medical Condition
316 Personality Traits or Coping Style Affecting Medical Condition
316 Maladaptive Health Behaviors Affecting Medical Condition
316 Stress-Related Physiological Response Affecting Medical Condition
316 Other or Unspecified Psychological Factors Affecting Medical Condition
316 Psychological Factors Affecting Medical Condition

So now, anyone with any other medical condition from cancer to heart disease will be evaluated by a psychiatrist to determine whether a “mental disorder”, “psychological symptoms”, “personality traits or coping style”, “maladaptive health behaviours”, “stress”, or, of course, “other unspecified psychological factors” are affecting their condition, say cancer?

This opens up the population of anyone with any other medical condition to psychiatrization, to psychotropic drugging, to being responsibilized for their – to use the same example – cancer.

Who on earth has a serious medical condition and is not experiencing “stress”?!?!?!  Or depression (maybe I’m going to die in 2 years…;) or anxiety (what are the biopsy results going to be?) or mania (I must do all of these things at warp speed just in case), etc., etc.

The effect on medicine will be extraordinary when (if, but more likely when) these new “disorders” are added.  People need to be made aware of this. I will be writing as much about this as I can, but I am only one voice.

“Selling Sickness” – Full-Length Documentary

If you’re starting (or have been doing so for a long time) to question the pharmaceutical industry, are interested about the rebranding of drugs for profit, the creation of new disorders to sell new pills, or the effects of SSRI antidepressants on children, I highly suggest you watch this documentary.  Dr. David Healy, a psychiatrist and author (one of my favourites), who is critical of the psychopharmaceutical industry is interviewed at length.

Here is the full-length documentary, broken into five parts:

Part One

Part Two

Part Three

Part Four

Part Five

Parents *love* to film their “bipolar children” and post the videos on youtube!

Here are some more videos of children afflicted with “Pediatric Bipolar Disorder” found on youtube.  Kids being kids, or kids with a psychiatric illness requiring strong medication?  You decide.  You know where I stand on the issue.

What is painfully obvious is that the parents of these children love to grab the camcorder, video-tape their bipolar behaviour in action (often while laughing…;), and post it on the internet.  If these kids aren’t permanently brain-damaged from taking medications never tested on the child population when they grow up, I’m sure they’ll be very happy with their parents.  So happy that they may even break down and have a bipolar outburst!

\”Bipolar Kids\”

More \”Bipolar Kids\”

More…

More Yet…

I told you, they love it!

…More

Even More!

more…

…more…

If only this was the end…

“Bipolar Kids”…

…so they cry and throw temper tantrums, and act “silly” at times?  I don’t know about you, but this makes it sound to me like all children are “bipolar”.  I better let Pfizer, Eli-Lily, and Astra-Zeneca know about my epiphany at once!!!

The Antichrist: Janice Papolos

The co-author of The Bipolar Child….(recall, her husband is a psychiatrist, she takes a liking to public speaking)

Warning: Do not seek out the full DVD unless you want to hear this woman speak at length about her and her psychiatrist husband’s “perfect life”, the phenomenon particular to Pediatric Bipolar Disorder of “Sleep Inertia” (trouble getting out of bed in the morning and winding down at night…how “abnormal”!), and long monologues about “how her heart just goes out to ‘these’ families!”

My First Boyfriend, The Serial Rapist (on why rape survivors are so often not believed, or are blamed for the event – Letter of Complaint #7 within)

Last summer, I finally gathered up the courage to make a police report about my first boyfriend, who turned out to be a serial rapist.  At the end of the tunnel, I found Alaryyk.

In high school, although I lost my virginity before others, during a stupid drunken parents-out-of-town party, I never had a “boyfriend”.  Any semblance of a “real” relationship, involving reciprocal love, existed only in my fantasies.  My best friend, however, was known for being “the hottest girl” within the group of other high school students that we socialized with during grades 10-12, and always had a boyfriend, and ten other boys pining for her, in line to be next.  At parties, boys just didn’t talk to me.  I realize now that this is probably because they were intimidated by my intelligence – I have never been able to talk just for the sake of talking, I like to discuss topics that require some thought and intelligence.  I took the biggest bong hits and was more than able to keep up with their drinking, but these boys ignored me to the point where I felt like a ghost, and started leaving parties without my absence even being noticed by my best friend or others.

As we are socialized to place such emphasis on appearance, I assumed my looks were the reason that boys were not interested in talking to me or pursuing a relationship with me.  It would take me until much later in life to realize this was not the case, and that I am beautiful, inside and out.  However, back in grade 12, my self-esteem was extremely low.  I did not fit in at all with my other peers – I never had.  From kindergarten to grade 12, first by force and then by choice, I spent more time in the hallway than in the classroom, although I always managed to end the year at the top of my classes.  I got along better with my teachers and workmates than other students my age – I was also the “poorest” girl in my class at the private all-girls school I went to from grades 7-12, and the only one that had a job (a full-time one, at that!) in addition to school.

Thus, when a new employee at work, a “man” called Josh that was a couple of years older than me (17) showed interest in me and then asked me out, this relationship immediately meant more to me than anything else.  I was sooooo in love.  I started dating this older, good-looking and charming fellow in November.  His calm responses when he found out about trauma I had experienced in my life, like the death of my mom, were a welcome change from the awkward responses of others my age.  I waited until our third date, like a good little Cosmipolitan Magazine reader.  However, something changed after I spent New Year’s Eve at a cabin with Josh and some of his friends.  Afterwards, he stopped calling me and his contract at work was not renewed – he had been hired as a “seasonal” employee.

My whole world was turned upside down.  I thought that I would never again find someone who loved and “understood” me.  I started using speed (self-medicating, I suppose) to deal with the deep depression I felt – I thought it enabled me to get my homework done and made the mandatory socialization that took place between me and my peers bearable.  Josh phoned a couple of times during February, inviting me to meet him late at night for sex in motel rooms, and I anxiously complied.  After that, I heard nothing from or of him, but I sent him an invitation to my Graduation in June.  He ended up replying and coming with me, and for the rest of that summer I saw him whenever I could.  Looking back, the time I spent with him consisted of me listening to him talk about his lofty ideas (delusions) about becoming a famous musician, writer, or businessman – something new every week – and having sex.  But I was hooked, addicted to this guy, not speed.

I moved to Montreal for my first year of University, but before leaving he said those “three little words every woman wants to hear!” and we decided to keep up our relationship, long distance.  A million “red flags” came up over the duration of my year away, and my visits back home.  He came to visit me at the end of September, and I finally got pregnant – I say “finally” not because I was trying to have a child with him, but because we had never used birth control.  I still resent my father for never talking to me about sex or birth control, instead choosing to pretend that sex didn’t exist, though I suppose I should have been a little smarter about things myself – I honestly believed I was magically unable to get pregnant.  He encouraged me to come back to Winnipeg to visit him over Thanksgiving weekend (mid-October in Canada), and I did.  When I got to his apartment, or rather the apartment that belonged to the special-needs man that it was his job to take care of (he would soon be fired when he was caught using this man’s computer to look at porn and jack off in the other room), I immediately felt nauseous, and overnight started vomiting…well things were coming out “both ends”.  He was sympathetic, but decided he had to attend a friend’s birthday party, although “he would only be gone an hour or so”.  When he finally came back at five in the morning after doing coke all night, he insisted that I perform a variety of sex acts on him until he came – not an easy task for someone that high on coke – and I complied.  I complied when he insisted on having sex with me two days after I had an abortion.  I complied when over Christmas break, he thought it would be funny for me and my best friend post-grade 12, Jima*, to disrobe and take the virginity of one of his friends (the one that everyone else made fun of).  Then, I listened to him call me every name in the book when he found out that Jima and I had taken some speed to get a little less inhibited, crying and begging for him not to break up with me.  In February, I spent reading week/spring break with him and his family in Florida.  I did not make a peep when he spent all of the money I had brought down for myself on cigars (his newest pretentious prop in the charm-act), or when on a drunken night he thought it would be funny to stick his dick up my ass without permission or warning.  This trip to Florida was the worst “vacation” I had ever experienced in my life, and I remember myself crying all the way back to Montreal on a plane, although I don’t know if my tears were as constant as they are in my memory.  Still, I stayed with him.

When I returned to Winnipeg in the summer, deciding to go to school there instead, he broke up with me after about a week.  I threw quite a fit, which ended in him raping me.  He insisted on having sex “one last time, come on, it’s what we’ve always been good at”, despite my cries for him to stop.  He whispered in my ear, “Every woman secretly wants to be raped.”  Later in the summer he called me to meet him for dinner and drinks, on a strictly plutonic basis.  He was working at a pub downtown.  When we walked through the front door, the hostess immediately broke down crying.  He told me to have a seat with some other friends of his that were at the pub, because he needed to speak with her “out back”.  When I asked him why she had been crying he told me that she had been sexually assaulted the previous weekend.  It would not be until the last few months of our relationship that he admitted to me, as he grew paranoid about his many secrets, that he had raped his coworker the previous weekend.  He also admitted that as a young teenager, he forced his five and seven year-old sisters to perform sex acts on him.  This, not drug use, as he previously claimed, was why he had been kicked out of his house by his parents at age 16.

After that summer, however, I thought our relationship was officially over – I had exorcised this “man” and would have nothing to do with him again.  When school started in the fall I was living with Jima, and he started calling our apartment constantly.  We got together a few times, and in no time I was back “in love”.  The two-bedroom apartment I shared with Jima and another friend was two small to house all four of us, so I agreed to move into another apartment with Josh and two other male roommates.  Josh managed to kick the first roommate out after a mere three months, shortly after he stopped working.  He would never work, or provide any financial support, from this point forward, except for a six-week gig at a telemarketing centre.  The drama he created around pushing this roommate out was a distraction.  I worked full-time, went to university full-time, and ate ramen noodles for almost every meal.  Josh’s sexual demands and temper tantrums were getting worse, and at the end of the day, as excited as I was to get “home”, I was terrified about what his behaviour would entail after I opened the door to our apartment.

At the end of a long, hot summer, he convinced me that our other roommate was a homicidal alcoholic, just as he was supposed to write his G.E.D. (he only had finished grade 9 or 10) and join me at university.  He did neither, and our next year living together, alone, was a living hell.  He often threatened that he would commit suicide if I didn’t have sex with him.  And despite my cries, he found a liking for sticking it up my ass whenever he felt like it.  I spent much time face down, my cries muffled by a pillow.  The emotional abuse was worse.  He constantly insulted my intelligence, threatened to “dump my ass again” (oh, how horrible that would have been!), and one event that sticks out in my memory is when I didn’t cook his eggs the right way and he threw them in my face, telling me that I had “fucked up once again”, and that our plans for the rest of the day were thus cancelled.  I was inconsolable, but lived with him for another entire year, telling no one of what was going on in our household, and believing that one morning I would wake up and everything would be better.

Instead, I woke up at the psych ward, and my previous blog posts all speak to what has happened after that.  It was actually him that dumped me, after warding me!  I was just “too fucked up for him”, *tear*, and he cried on Jima’s shoulder, who still had no idea about the abuse.  While I was in the hospital, he raided our apartment of everything that was of any worth – rare books, the “good” pots and pans, the cat my sister had gotten me as a birthday present, the video game consoles and games – all items that I had purchased (except for the kitty, that is).  At the hospital I met my next long term relationship, Evan*, a recovering drug addict posing as someone with “bipolar disorder”.  I did not learn that drugs were the reason he had been in the hospital until after we had both been released and were living together (I really had no where else to go, Josh had severed my relationships with family and friends, even with Jima).  The on-again, off-again relationship – the off periods being during his bouts of mass consumption of any drug he could get his hands on – was a relationship of convenience, and he was supposed to move to Vancouver with me, but (thank goddess) moved on to heroin instead.

It was not until I learned of other women in Winnipeg, including a childhood friend, that Josh had raped, that I decided to report him to the police.  I was interviewed by a female officer, and had to describe every dirty detail of what he had done to me, and what I knew of what he had done to others.  Obviously, this was not a pleasant process.  I have not been called to testify, but wasn’t really expecting much, I just wanted it out of my life, and on official record, in case another brave woman out there reports it immediately, when she has a “night” with my ex-boyfriend, the serial rapist.

Shortly after I made the report, a male friend from Winnipeg who had been friends with both Josh and me, got in touch with me and told me he had been planning a trip to British Columbia to visit friends, and that we should see each other.  I did not feel comfortable seeing him if 1) he had any sexual expectations (we had a bit of a fling after the Josh break-up, during one of Evan’s “I love crack!” periods), or 2) he was still friends with Josh, or would continue to be after I told him about the hell he had put me through for the years that we were together.  I hadn’t spoken to him about the details before, although I thought we shared the opinion that the guy was a loser, so I shared them with him in an e-mail – all was fresh in my mind after making that police report.  This is the response I got back:

scars,

I am not sure if you are suggesting that I suddenly do not, or if you are looking to judge me in some way, but obviously I do.

I just don’t want to have to get in the middle of some major league “war of the roses” or have to wonder about what Is being said behind my back because I laughed at a joke, or didn’t laugh at the right one, OR if someone Is going to try and imagine there is some great sexual need to go ALL THE WAY to BC over. I am sure you know such things are all too easily had right here in Manitoba.

You seem to feel there is alot going on, more than there is.  Some hidden agenda, or some thing to hate over.

You are the one who changed plans, and I cna’t say I blame you. there is no hard feelings but I am beginning think you may have some Anti-male views and see them all as child molesters thieves and rapists.

I think Joch may have his flaws and Any time people split up, there is grounds for acrimony. IT’s understandable.

In the time I have known you you ahve told me things about your father, Jima, Joch, and even had some unkind words about me that returned while I was thinking everything was just fine between us.

Can I ever know for sure the reponse to my face is the same as what gets said behind my back?

I am not pointing fingers, I am not perfect.

Do you look for the worst in people? IS is your chief area of focus, do their other sides matter?

Once there was the slightest, and I mean slightest gap in opinion You immediately jump off the deep end imagining there must be some sexual agenda.

If I ahd been going with that purpose in mind, or If more singlemindedly ahd that purpose only, either way, I’d have enquired to amke sure I didn’t wante my time, but that was NOT anything to do with the purpose.

I have someone in my life that I am initmate with, and I don’t go outside of that agreement. I trust her, she trusts me.

Please don’t take this the worng way but we are not right for each other that way.

Scars, You are well known for having multiple partenrs at once, and I am not condemning that, there was a time, where I didn’t give a damn, either.

THe fact is, I am much more cautious and health conscious for taking those kind of chances.

I hope your life is great, but I don’t care whether you are getitng it every night with 5 different partners or saving yourself for a big Lesbian Wedding night. It’s none of my business. IT’s whatever is right for you, and your concern alone.

IT has nothing to do with me. But thanks for thinking I would hinge a hiuge trip across the countrey jsut for a roll in the hay.

Do you see how demeaning and insulting that is?

DOn’t worry, IT’s forgiven.

But this quality of jumping to look for the very worst possible triat in people whether true or not, logical or not, doesn’t send me a good message.

Jima was your best friend for years but still you resent like hell, you think she stole money from you, and yet you are willing to go into business with her. [personal comment - ???? - he is referring to a spat Jima and I had over $300 when we were 18...as for "going into business", I guess that's how this guy refers to a "friendship"?]

You claim she took some $2000.00 form you but she maintains you were paid abck and spent the money on drugs yourself.

If she were lying, why on Earth would you go back in business with her unless you knew her to be honest and not a thief?

So who is lying?

Or do you just prefer to focus on the fact that the money was taken and then forget about the repayment?

SO you are not crazy about Jima, sometimes, OK.

SO Josh is the  Child molesting anti Christ, rapist.

SO too now is Evan?

Me?

THe only thing in common with all of these people and you, Is..YOU.

SO is it that everyone is a thieving raping evil doer, or is it jsut your version.

I have met Josh’s Girlfriend many times, and she is neither threatened by him nor a rape victim.
[personal comment: a mere few days later, Jima would tell me about Josh's break-up with who was, indeed, his latest victim]
I have over 25 girlfriends and never once and kind of accusation.

Jima has been honerable in all her dealings with all who know her and no one seems to question her character for any reason.

Until we get ot Scars, who maintains ALL of these people are guilty sinners of heinous crimes.

Are they? Are we?

Are you?

Yuo say you ahve been raped multiple times by Multiple men, yet you also showed me a paer indicating you’d have sex with anyone who dared to lay beside you. [personal comment - ??? a "paer"?  I cannot for the life of me think of what this may refer to...]

If you see a credibility issue here let me know.

I have never known anyone to begin a sentence “I woke up without any pants on and with two strange men and similar types.

Multiple rapes by multiple men. DO you know pattern behaviour is?   Have you ever known anyone who puts themselves at risk more often than you?

Are you so free from your own harsh judging eye, that it is easier for you to paint everyone else in the role of the villain and you the victim, or is it a card played to perfection?

Are you honest with yourself about things?

YEah, I was looking forward to seing you, and I DO enjoy your company, and you have an incredible mind.

You also have little regard for the reputations of others.

I was a little troubled about what you had to say about Josh. Not because I disbeleive you, but rather how carelessy you make accusations.

None of your other friends or former friends say things about you that are exaggerated or focussed on the lowest common denominator or demagoguery.

That is why Jima believed Josh over you.
Me over You. IT’s why Josh believes Jima over You. Me over You. It’s why I believe Josh and Jima.

Not because I think you dishonest, or misinformed, but I know if you want to undermine someone’s reputation, You don’t care whether what you are saying is fair. If you ahve all the facts, or If it comes off a little turmped up, as long as you get your digs in.

It’s reckless and mean. and worst of all, It makes people distrust you.  You may well have all kinds of facts in hand, but the character and principles to keep honest and fair seem lacking at times, and that Is why people have reservations about you.

Not because you aren’t bright or insightful or they want to have sex with you.  IT’s about the repsonsibility that comes with being a fairminded person.

But don’t take my word for it. Ask all your closest friends.

Personally, I hope you do become a lesbian, but what will you claim when they run afoul of you?

Not much pity out there for the victim of abusive woman is there?

I hope you find this to be of some use.

Good Luck Scars.

*end e-mail*

For about 20 minutes, after skimming over this unexpected response, I felt like I was going crazy – maybe he was right!  Maybe I had brought upon all of the abuse myself.  Maybe it is normal for boyfriends to force sex on their girlfriends.  Aside all that, I had kept it to myself for so many years.  I went to sleep feeling very confused and upset.

I woke up realizing how wrong this guy was, and how his response represented the response survivors of sexual abuse often get.

It is your fault.  You are vilifying people.  You are exaggerating.  You are just trying to make so-and-so look bad.  You were drunk.  You were asking for it.

I shared the e-mail with several female and male friends, from both Winnipeg and Vancouver, and they assured me that I was in the right.  And so I responded to his e-mail:

___ ____, Josh’s mom, who could talk for hours about how the sexual abuse of his sisters ripped their family apart, and shamed them from their circle of friends.
___ _____- Josh’s dad, who kicked him out of the house at age 16 because of the incest
____ and _____ ____ – Josh’s sisters who endured his sexual abuse
Dr. ____ ____ – I guess psychoanalysis files are confidential, but the police could change that…and speaking of police:
The Winnipeg Police Department – Josh has been served with more than one restraining order
____ _____ – Josh and my former roommate
____ _____ – my father, who loaned Josh tens of thousands of dollars
The Canada Revenue Agency – who Josh also has extensive debts with
____ ______ – A fellow Chapters employee who knew both me and Josh, and drove me home at night, often fearing what I would face as I turned the key – he witnessed his abuse at the store shortly before Josh walked out throwing a temper tantrum (You know he never once paid rent, the whole two years we lived together, don’t you?  I mean, he was never employed or on assistance during that period, you know that…who do you think bought all of the groceries and booze and toiletries…??)
___ – the Australian girl that he worked with at the pub – I’m sure I could find her number with all the social networking available
____ ____ – my little sister, who stayed at the apartment with Josh and me and witnessed his psychopathic behaviour (not a word I use casually)
I don’t really care what you think, because I know everything I told you is the truth and nothing but the truth.  In fact, I skimmed through this long winded, incoherent treatise you’ve just sent me and chose not to read it.  My body knows what it has been through, and no words can convince me that I did not experience what I experienced.  I may be many unsavoury things, I may have told lies in the past to get out of trouble with the law, but I would never EVER lie about rape and incest.  I have a feeling ____, ______, and _______ would feel the same way.
You have joined a legacy of men (and some women) who chose to call survivors of sexual abuse liars.  This is one of the most vivid illustrations of the illness of our society, and the state of the feminist movement.
You are definitely not fit/ready for the West Coast – we’re a little ahead of that mindset – hopefully the rest of the continent will catch up, or turn to dust, as is happening in the deserts of the American south…
You may very well have inspired a paper I will publish after publishing my first one with Heidi, on why women are called liars when they bravely admit to being survivors of rape and incest…the many possible theories are brewing in my head.  It certainly won’t be dedicated to you, but you can take pride in the fact that you were the impetus for the study, and sitting in a bar alone one day, you can babble on about it to some other misogynists who will boost your ego – they’ll be very impressed indeed, while they pretend to know what “sociology” and “academic journals” are.  I thought you belonged here for a few days there, but I was sadly mistaken – you belong in that dingy bar, filled with bikers and women looking for sex for money or affection, lobotomized slot-machine addicts, bikers, and the like.  There, you will always be the smartest guy in the room. [comment: these are the types of bars this fellow goes to, and he told me several stories about how superior he was to everyone else there before this e-mail exchange]
ps -

One line I did read as I scrolled down quite quickly was a list of people who “all have one thing in common – me”

This reminded me very much of something I read somewhere before, so I pondered about it for a minute and then giggled as I realized it’s from “Sex and the City”
‘Carrie realized these men all had one thing in common – her!’
Did you steal this idea from an episode of “Sex and the City”?  Nice!  Or if not, you should avoid telling women this line in the future because it’s not very original.

You see, the thing those people actually have in common is that they are NO LONGER IN MY LIFE.  I have countless other dear friends and former lovers and acquaintances who ARE in my life, and have been since long before I knew you or Josh.  And that’s because they are NOT rapists, heroin addicts, perpetrators of incest, losers, thieves, and the like.
*end of conversation, end of contact*
…and so I encourage all survivors of sexual abuse to stand strong, never doubting themselves over people who make wild accusations about one’s own role in being abused.  Indeed, we know what our bodies and our selves have been put through, and no one can take this away, though we so often wish someone could.  And I advise any younger readers to realize that high school is not life, and that one day you too will look in the mirror and realize how beautiful you are, even if there is not a lover at your side.  And, last but not least, I encourage you to go through the painful process of reporting abuse to the police.
Official statistics state that one in three Canadian women will be raped within their lifetime.  Considering how few sexual offences are reported, what is the real statistic?
Again, unfortunate but true, we must take this unacceptable reality into our own hands and fight it like we are fighting for our lives (and we are), if it is to change.
I leave you with this powerful song from my favourite musical artist of all time, Tori Amos, who is also the founder of R.A.I.N.N. – The Rape, Abuse, and Incest National Network, whose webpage can be viewed at www.rainn.org  It was not until I filed the report and “came out” as a survivor of rape and sexual abuse, that I could bear listening to this track from her first album, Little Earthquakes.