Tag Archives: sociology of psychiatry

What is the “Practice of Madness”?

…a double entendre.

We are a couple of certified “madpeople”, but are also graduate students in the Sociology of Medicine, Psychiatry, and “Madness”.  Thus, we “practice madness” in our daily dealings in society – one that is quite mad, itself.

Psychiatry, on the other side of the coin, is also a “practice of madness”, as we are doled our brain-disabling pills, and more and more people are “psychiatrized” and given “diagnoses” from the pages of the DSM – the “Bible of Psychiatry” (available in full for download above).

This site is…

…as we play around with web-design, and try to make this look more like our old wordpress site: http://journeynotdestination.wordpress.com.  For the time being, please check out the archives to get a taste of what we’re all about.  We will have the new site up and running as soon as two crazies can get it together :wink: – considering our doctors usually think we’re “hypomanic”, that should be pretty soon!

Neuroethics Blog

I have mentioned the topic of “neuroethics” briefly, which takes a critical approach to brain-scanning technology such as the fMRI, and the claims that it can do everything from diagnose bipolar disorder to detect when people are telling lies.

I found a great blog, here on wordpress, devoted to the topic, that anyone interested should check out.  I will be posting my essay on the use of brain scans to diagnose psychiatric disorders in children in mid-June.  For now, this site explores many of the problems with the technology, as well as it’s frightening applications, in fields such as…

Neuromarketing!

Insomnia and “The Dilemma”

As I am writing this post at 2:49 am, Pacific Standard Time, the reason for this topic is rather obvious – I cannot sleep.

Only this time, I don’t have an answer as to why sleep will not have me.  I’ve gone through the lists of meds, side-effects, and interactions, which usually leads to some understanding of why my body is doing what it is doing.  I often point my doctors in the right direction, I often hear them respond, “That’s interesting.  That’s probably it.”

This is when I realize I am facing “The Dilemma” of psychiatry/madness/crazy, that I laughed at a couple of weeks ago when watching the Canadian short film, “That Crazy Game Called Life”.  The animated short feature shows a number of playing cards being turned over, that dictate this little character’s experience of current mental “health treatment”.  The playing cards end up actually being flashcards, like the ones I used to study in high school, and they provoke thought.  Underneath “The Dilemma” a very short, but very concise definition was given…

Side-effect or Symptom?

Yes, I am staring at the dilemma just like this little guy.  Should I ask my doc for another pill, something to help me sleep?  I cringe at the idea, the last thing I want is another vial of psychopharmaceuticals, but I’m pretty useless when I haven’t slept; I, like all human beings, get a little “psychotic” when I haven’t slept for days.  If I chose this option, I would like to be able to take into good faith the fact that I am experiencing a “symptom” – of “bipolar disorder” or whatever you want to call it, as we all know I reject the DSM‘s labels and static lists of criteria for “disorders” – being a little different, and having problems with things like sleeping or eating enough or concentrating on “the right task” or being able to silence my brain, in this case, to silence it enough to let it fall asleep after a busy day.

Or, is this some side-effect of my current medications, in which case I would like to remedy that the rational way – to get rid of whatever is making me type right now instead of dream.  This seems less likely, at first, as my psych meds haven’t changed for over a year.  Then again, who knows when a new side-effect might pop up – the trials completed on the pills I take only monitored participants for eight weeks.  Is my brain just a ticking time-bomb, armed and ready to explode with yet another side-effect at any time?  Will this get progressively worse?

By listening to my body and researching these drugs – often an incredibly depressing process, but my desire to learn new things and piece together my own puzzle has redeeming qualities – I can often “figure it out”.  But research only extends as far as it exists.  I am reminded that the long-term consequences of psychopharmaceuticals remain a mystery, not just to me, but to everyone, from patient to doctor, from pharmacist to Big Pharma.

The fact that this time I cannot resolve “The Dilemma” is unsettling …and not helpful with falling asleep.

“Mind Over Meds”

Cheers to Lori for this excellent NY Times Magazine article, about a psychiatrist reconsidering the dogma of diagnosis via the DSM.

Documentary – “Money Talks: Profits Before Patient Safety”

TV surprised me and there was an excellent documentary/short animated film called “That Crazy Game Called Life”, a National Film Board of Canada (NFB) production, on this afternoon.  Unfortunately, whereas the NFB used to provide all of their films in full on their website, they evidently can no longer afford to do so.  You can read about it here though!  And here’s a great still from it…

For now let’s check this one out…it’s primetime TV time.  Gross.  I didn’t realize people still watched “American Idol”.  I’ll watch it too…

Grrrr…the embed code is not working and I am sick and lazy :razz: You can watch it here on blip.tv.  Very lazy, I know! :oops:

Documentary: Big Bucks, Big Pharma: Marketing Disease and Pushing Drugs

The title of this documentary is quite self-explanatory.  The multi-billion dollar pharmaceutical industry is explored, focusing on “Direct to Consumer Advertising” – stuff like that in the “Ads and Commercials” category of this blog.

Big Bucks, Big Pharma

a rant before going into interzone, 2005

I must have written this early in the morning of the day that I disappeared for several before New Year’s, finding myself in a bathtub at my dad’s house, trying to die on New Year’s Eve.  Does it give me any insight into why I disappeared?  Unfortunately not.  It’s interesting though…

3:44 am, Tuesday December 27, 2005

A rant.

The children are sleeping all safe in their beds and I’m sitting here paralyzed because I cannot figure out how to turn on my iRiver mp3 player.

I press the button that says “power” at least a hundred times.

I read the troubleshooting manual at least ten times.

I give up.  I want to break the little metal gadget into a thousand pieces using a hammer and a little adrenaline.

But of course one cannot do this, for it would render the tiny harddrive unreturnable.

So I sit here and loathe technology and loathe myself for being so incapable.

I sit here and think fondly of bed, but have no desire to lie down.

I am a bad person.

Not bad in the traditional sense.  I don’t throw garbage out into the streets, I vote, social injustices have brought me to tears, I’ve turned off the TV.

No, I am bad in a much subtler way.  I don’t care about myself as much as others care for me.  And I don’t care for you nearly as much as you care for me.

Not to say you wouldn’t have found yourself in the same predicament, anxious to explore the far reaches of your mind after an afternoon of shopping that was supposed to provide some sense of satisfaction, but instead made you embarassed, embarassed to show anyone how many clothes you’d bought and how nicely they would match your iRiver as you walk towards a seat on the bus.

Money.  Is evil, makes the world go round, is the root of all evil, is necessary.  I cringe thinking of future dealings I will be forced to have with this reified symbol of value.  I cringe thinking of the sixty-six dollars I will have to ask my father for tomorrow, my weekly allowance from the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority.  Did I mention I’m insane?  I cringe thinking of meetings at banks, maximum-growth savings accounts, GICs, RRSPs.  I want out but out is not an option.  I was born into this system, and by this system I will die.

I suppose the mention of insanity perked up your ears or your eyes or whatever sense organ you are absorbing this rant through.  Only 20% of psychiatrists agree with each other on a given diagnosis.  So I’ve been given a number of trophies for my deviation from sanity.  Borderline personality disorder, anxiety disorder, major depression, bipolar disorder, schizotypal disorder, obsessive-compulsive tendencies.

I agree with each of these diagnoses.  They reference pages in the bible of psychiatry upon which descriptions of the various “disorders” are given.  And each of those pages describes me to a T.  I’m even getting a study grant from the government because of my madnesses, and would encourage you to step up to the plate – you never know what seemingly insignificant idiosyncracy could earn you a couple grand in grants or bursaries.

Embrace your neuroses!  Make love to your psychoses!  Then turn around and quietly laugh at that man on the bus with untied shoelaces who is having a loud conversation, with himself.

Functional-crazy.  That’s what it’s all about.

You put your left hand in, you pull your left hand out, you put your left hand in and you shake it all about.  Do you know who you’re voting for this January?

You’re about to be exposed to one belief I hold that may offend you: democracy doesn’t work.

Most of us won’t be voting for anyone, as we know which neighbourhoods corresspond with certain political parties.  Those of us who do vote will not vote for the candidate we like the most, but for the candidate we loathe the least.  Stephen Harper looks like an alien from planet G94/B, Paul Martin looks like he’s had an eyebrow lift, Jack Lleyton is a smaller man with a mustache.  And then there are those crazy separatistes in Quebec.  Looks like Mr. I Can’t Stop Opening my Eyes this Wide will win.

4:17 am now.  I have a vast array of tranquilizers and downers that could put me fast to sleep but I leave them on the shelf.

I refuse to sleep until this iRiver turns on.

I refuse to eat until I am unhealthy looking, a look I pull off well.

In high school the cold, veiny hands of a girl with bad circulation were endearingly termed, “Jen hands”.

And you expect me to be a good person?

To watch the evening news, to take it seriously?  To take economics or commerce or business because I will surely find my dream job within one of those disciplines?  To refuse Joe the dealer, when he shows up at my doorstep with his kool-aid green hair flying in all directions?

I’d rather be sent to the principal’s office, just one more time.  For laughing too hard or crying too hard, for distracting the teacher or distracting my peers, for yelling too loud or refusing to speak.  I would sit in that principal’s waiting area, palms sweaty, eyes darting around, stomach acid churning.  A disappointed glance and a call home to mom and dad.  Same thing every time, so why do I still get nervous?

The worst punishment I ever endured was a few days off school during which I drove around the city with my ne’er do well friends and smoked drugs.  Of course, I was thinking about the implications of my actions the whole time.  The implications were – nothing!  I was just a certain woman or man’s favourite underling to make an example of.  Arsonist, smoker, junkie, counterfeit artist, vandal, stoner, scrapper – just like those pages of the psychiatrist’s bible, I could be described by many unsavoury terms.  Now look what will happen to you if you venture out into that territory.

4:32.  Time goes fast for a little while and then slows back down, sometimes so much that it seems the clock is ticking backwards.  Right now it proceeds at a normal speed, simply stating the strange hour that is upon me, reminding me that good citizens will be getting up for their morning runs in one hour, reminding me that I stopped going to bed at a reasonable hour almost a decade ago.  It never mattered anyways.  I would always be exhausted in the morning, whether I’d had eight or three hours of sleep.  What difference does it make?  Does it make you nervous to imagine writing that final exam after only three hours of sleep?  Well then you probably won’t do very well, being so nervous and all.

4:37.  It sounds like a flight – flight 437 from Vancouver to Winnipeg, from Tokyo to Vancouver, from Melbourne to Tokyo, then back again.  My father spent six months in Europe when he was my age and has sworn off travelling since.  I guess he was disillusioned somehow.  Whenever I’ve travelled I’ve departed this strip-mall sea of a city with absolutely no expectations, so I’ve always had a great time, too great, I’ve always wanted never to return home, where things are like this, where things are just so.

4:41 and I can feel the bags forming underneath my eyes, but it doesn’t matter because in my bag I have M.A.C. hyperreal foundation 300 and a tube of mascara that could make your heart break.  I can look beautiful falling apart, like the ruins of Babylon or something like that, that likening myself to shows my heinousness.

I’ve been careful lately to apply eye-liner and lipstick.  Doing little things like putting on make-up make us feel better about ourselves.  Take care of yourself.  I never was too good at that, but I’m getting better, says #240 “pink freeze” eyeshadow.  I’m getting better.

Better enough to go to school in less than ten days.  I wish I could tell you that I have my notebooks ready, my books purchased, my schedule memorized.  I wish that were me but it is not.  I won’t know what time my first class is until the day of, and I’ll shove some lined paper into a bag, and miss the first bus because I’m looking for a pen.  And I’ll get through the work, get top marks, clinging on to success with the tips of my fingers, looking down at failure and wishing I could just let myself drop into the abyss of not caring.  I pretend not to care but that’s an easy one – you know I care, if I didn’t maybe I would have gotten through registration day without crying.

Bureaucracy makes me ill.  Vomiting would have been more a propos than crying, but I’m a slave to my body’s involuntary reactions.  I haven’t been able to vomit for a long time.  Even when I’ve been deathly ill I’ve still had to force it out, sticking two fingers down my esophagus.  I miss being able to puke without such prodding.

New Year’s Eve is in four days.  It always messes me up to think about where I was last New Year’s and where I am now.  It’s one of those few times you have two clear reference points and can trace how one year influenced the next year, but in so many more ways than you could have imagined.  At the same time you can view what was so very important to you one year means nothing to you now.  Don’t shed a tear, I’m not trying to be sentimental, fuck, anything but sentimental, I’m only looking at the start from the finish line.  Out of breath and wild-eyed.  Heaving.

I never won a race and I quit every type of lesson I embarked upon before the third session, so I was never given ribbons or trophies of any sort.  I received the highest mark in my grade almost every year, so I was given a certificate and a scholarship.  But academics aren’t like sports or boy scouts or camp, no one stands cheering you on, and no one hears your name for it is said quietly, it is not yelled.

I would prefer for my name to be said quietly though.  Yelling is loud and tacky, especially when he or she who yells feels it necessary to add on a bunch of syllables to the name they shout.  Like ______________ _________.  That’s not my name.  My name is ___.  I was born in the eighties and my parents were unoriginal.

5:04 am.  Winter provides me with soothing darkness at this earlyist of hours.  But the days are already growing longer, a little longer each day until the light at 5:04 am is blinding.  Not tonight.  Tonight I may lay under the covers after taking a cocktail of pills and feel quite safe.

My favourite instant is that when you turn out the last lamp and for a few seconds there is only blackness.  Quickly things take back their form and place, but for an instant they didn’t exist.  I didn’t exist.  No, that’s wrong, if I didn’t exist there would be no blackness.

5:09 am.  I wonder how much longer I could keep typing for.  I wonder when it would stop making sense, or if it already has.  I wonder what tomorrow will bring, probably nothing worth speaking of in a week.  I should really take the pills I was supposed to take almost twelve hours ago now, the chemicals that make me sleep.

Lately it’s hardly sleep though, just nightmares and waking up in cold sweats.  Nightmares that Josh is still here, that you said ‘no’, that I forgot the wrong thing at the wrong time and thus will cease to live.

I’ve thoroughly enjoyed this last night of casting off random words and thoughts into the void.  Of course I’ve learned nothing, of course I’m not done yet.  But done is being forced upon me by the concerned citizens close to me, and we never really learn, we are just given ideas to ponder in the hope that maybe, just maybe, someday we’ll come up with one of our own.

Clocks are tripe, time is meaningless.  Good luck convincing them of that one.  Just take your pills, five down the hatch and one up the ol’ nose.  How I do enjoy sucking foreign substances up into my nostrils through a straw-type instrument.  How far we are apart from one another, how much you will never understand about me, how much I will never understand about you.  How close we are to one another, trudging through the same snow, walking over that same path day after day.  And I don’t even know your name.  One of my biggest problems is that I don’t know how or when to stop.  When funny’s become absurd, when philosophy’s become a rant, when a rant’s become an evening and the evening’s almost over.

How could I ever have a family, children of my own?  How could I raise them, seeing the chaos that underlines each second of our being?  I gather I could do quite well, but I would never be called a good mother.  The good mothers would feel little shocks of superiority every time I walked past and gave them an opportunity to sneer.  Bad bad bad.

If bad and good are really all we’re made of, I’ve got something else coming to me.  But fuck, I may take drugs from strangers and dance the night away instead of studying, but I walk to school and I don’t go to Starbucks and I don’t even have TV.

I suppose good is the norm, and the norm always tends towards mediocrity.  I suppose bad is the unknown, and the unknown is not governed by the rules of statistics.  The unknown is all we have.  No, we don’t have time, and we hardly have space.  We don’t know.  I don’t know.  You don’t know.  Nobody knows.

And that makes life worth a little more.  Each answer is echoed by a new question, and that makes us infinite.  Infinite ugliness, infinite beauty, infinite sound and infinite light.  I only wish I could know how the story ends.

I suppose it ends happily ever after.

Titicut Follies: Full Length Documentary

The famed, banned documentary, captures everyday life in a mental institution in 1967, and showed the world the violence and abusive treatment that inmates were subject to for the first time.  This film is a must-see for anyone who is interested in psychiatry.  It should be a must-see for everyone.  I can’t see many people disagreeing with the fact that the horrors captured on film here are human rights abuses of the highest order.  What struck me when I first watched it, aside from the horror, was that the patients make a hell of a lot more sense than the doctors, even those who are markedly “psychotic”.

I got my hands on an “underground copy”.  Here it is in full for your enjoyment.  Perfect for a Saturday movie night :)

Super Fun Quiz!!!

hehe…no, actually not so much.

So when I got my prescriptions for a bunch of pills (for my physiological problems) the other day that I had never taken before, I went to look them up on www.rxlist.com.  I haven’t had the need to look up the side-effects of drugs on that site for some time, and I don’t remember being so violently advertised to – to take an “Are You Depressed?” quiz sponsored by Eli-Lily, of course, the same folks that bring us the groundbreaking “mood tracker diary”, and are generous enough to distribute them for free.  Maybe soon they’ll be sitting beside the bible in the drawer of all hotel rooms.  The ad had an image of a blonde female model with her head looking downwards in feigned despair.  I guess this is intended to imply – even the richest, best looking people in the world can suffer from “major depression”.  You’re in good company.

The questions on these quizzes seem to be getting more and more abstract.  Phrases like “Do you feel _____ or ______ or ____?”  appear even more than they used to.  More and more “ors” begets more and more people that will get the same answer I did when I submitted my results – you are at “high risk” for having Major Depression, and you should print this sheet off and “talk to your doctor”.

Here are the 10 questions that are to determine whether or not one of Eli-Lily’s “antidepressant” medications is a must have for you – answer yes or no (my cynical comments in italics):

1. I feel sad or down most of the time.  (Sad OR “down”?  ”Down”.  Doesn’t get much more ambiguous than that.)

2. I’ve lost interest in the activities I used to enjoy.  (Pretty standard.)

3. I feel tired almost every day.  (I could rant about this one for pages.  In sum, who the hell doesn’t feel tired these days?!?  2 hour commutes to work in either direction, dealing with endless bureaucracy, struggling desperately to pay bills…feeling tired is not “abnormal”.  A society that exhausts us to the point that we have no time for leisure is abnormal.  Just as a declining quality of entertainment has been linked with the decline of a society, so has the diminishment of time for leisure – time to get in touch with your creativity or actually speak with your family members or friggin’ go ice skating.)

4. I have problems sleeping. I’m either sleeping too much or staying awake at night. (“Or” number two.  Unless you’re getting precisely eight hours per night, you’re abnormal.)

5. My appetite has changed. I’m not eating enough, or I’m eating too much.  (“Or” number three.  Your appetite must always be the same!!!  Actually, no.  The human body evolved such that it could withstand going through periods without much food, followed by times of surplus food.  This is a natural cycle.  Women especially, like the waif that I clicked on to take this quiz, are more hungry at some times during their monthly cycle and less at others.  So, ladies, I guess we can all answer yes to this one.  One free “yes”!  Whoo-hoo!)

6. I have trouble concentrating.  (Again, pretty standard.  And we live in a world with so few distractions, that anyone who cannot concentrate is obviously wrong in the head ;) )

7. My friends say I’m acting different. I’m either anxious and restless or lethargic.  (“Or” number four.  ”My friends say…” – so is this question to be answered solely on the basis of others’ opinions?  It’s not really clear.  It basically is a repeat of questions six and three, no?  I’m either anxious and restless {trouble concentrating} or lethargic {tired}.  So if you answered “yes” to either of those questions, you get a yes for this one too.  Congratulations!)

8. I feel worthless or hopeless.  (“Or” number five!  …”Worthless”…as in not worth any money?  …”Hopeless”… I have no hope of earning any money anytime soon?  Alright, I’ll calm down on the political economy stuff.  Still, two more very ambiguous words.  Excuse me, feelings.)

9. I’m having frequent headaches, stomach problems, muscle pain, or back problems.  (“Or” times 4!  So we’re at a grand total of 9 “ors”.  What the hell do these things have to do with needing an antidepressant?!?!?!?!?!?!)

10. I find myself thinking a lot about dying.  (I think this used to be a question about “suicidal ideation”, much different than thinking about dying.  For one, it is healthy to think about death, the American cultural avoidance of the topic is abnormal.  Furthermore, who isn’t thinking about death in our paradoxically “apocalypse”-obsessed culture?  Especially if we never talk about it?  2012 is just around the corner…every Sunday the “History Channel” devotes the entire day to apocalypse-scenario programming.  Good grief.)

Results:  If you answered “yes” to five or more of these questions, ask your doctor for some psychotropic drugs.

I wonder what they tell you if you only answer yes to four…I’ll give it a try…

“Lower Risk”!!  ” You replied that you are feeling four or fewer of the common symptoms of depression. In general, people experiencing depression have five or more common symptoms of the condition. But every individual is unique. If you are concerned about depression, talk with your doctor.

So either way, just having clicked on the picture of the blonde chick means you need to talk with your doctor.  If you are “concerned” about depression, you’re probably depressed.

The following statement which follows each suggestion (either “Lower Risk” or “High”;) is especially intriguing:

Depression shows up in many different ways. People often lose interest in favorite activities and feel sad or hopeless. They may also have sleep problems, gain or lose weight, feel irritable or angry, or be in physical pain for unexplained reasons. Feeling guilty, anxious, or having difficulty concentrating are also common signs of depression. Fortunately, there are many ways to treat depression, and more than 80% of people treated for depression improve within a year.

Within a year?! Eli-Lily’s antidepressants all claim to work within three to six weeks… I guess they’ve decided to cut themselves a little more slack?  Or make enough time to manufacture another antidepressant “add-on” like Abilify, to keep up with the rest of their drugs that do not work.

I’m going to print out my “results” and…

wipe my ass with them :)

Sensationalism vs. Sensationalism: “Psychaitry: An Industry of Death” film + review

Last night, after finally getting some pain relief, Alaryyk and I watched the documentary I posted here a few days back, “Psychiatry: An Industry of Death”.

The narrator of the film sounded like an announcer at a “monster truck” event.  The captions looked like those from an episode of “24″ (I’ve never watched this show myself, but I’ve seen the commercials) or some other “terrorism/CIA”-related North American primetime drama.  I have to add the “North” to “American”, because sadly, Canada now has a show of this genre.  At least knowing the record of success that CRTC funded Canadian TV programming has had, it will be off the air by the end of the month. :lol:

The statistics provided were outlandish both in their presentation and their lack of any reference as to where they had come from.  Numbers of billions of dollars spent on the “Industry of Death” flash across the screen, as do numbers of deaths of psychiatric patients, which I can say from a well-researched perspective, were exaggerated.

However, many of my favourite theorists from the field of the Sociology of Medicine and Psychiatry were interviewed, albeit in 30 second clips, including Andrew Scull – author of the fantastic book Making Us Crazy, Robert Whitaker – author of the fabulous historical book Mad in America, and Thomas Szasz – the psychiatrist and author of a canon of critical books such as The Myth of Mental Illness and The Medicalization of Everyday Life. As Benjamin Rush is to “The Father of Psychiatry”, Thomas Szasz is to “The Father of Anti-Psychiatry”.  But I don’t think that analogy will be appearing on any standardized exams anytime soon.

The history of madness presented in the documentary is completely accurate, but the narrator’s voice was incredibly distracting, as were flashing red and black screens of the aforementioned numerical figures.

Thus, I can see why those familiar with this history could be quite peeved with the style of the film – I was.  But it got me thinking… the documentary imitated the “infotainment” genre that characterizes the evening news, and the self-proclaimed “documentaries” presented on television, from Dog, the Bounty Hunter to Dateline to the bizarre MSNBC programs that are supposed to depict the reality of supermax prisons in the United States – I recall one called Lockdown (having worked at a jail, and after studying prisons for a year, I found these much more irresponsible, as the images depicted were absolutely not reflective of reality).

But is the only way to fight back against sensationalism to use sensationalism to present your own message?  If “Psychiatry: An Industry of Death” were shown on television, would it attract and educate more viewers than a more “toned down” documentary about the history of “madness”, the abuse of psychiatric patients, and the number of people that develop permanent tardive dyskenisa (presents similarly to Parkinson’s Disease) or die each year as a result of taking psychiatric drugs/being subjected to ECT?  Would the general public find the information more or less believable?

The answer is – I have no idea.  I am turned off by sensationalist television myself, but apparently, the majority of North Americans are not.

Incredibly important footage that the public needs to be exposed to – such as the drugging of Russian communist dissenters with antipsychotic/neruoleptic drugs, to disable the parts of their brains responsible for “critical and lofty thoughts” – is included.

In sum, the film was completely accurate in its historical depiction of psychiatry and some of the most important scholars in this field of sociology were introduced, but the statistics seemed (and some definitely were) very exaggerated, and the narrator’s commanding tone, which could also be compared to that of Robert Stack, the original narrator of Unsolved Mysteries, and constant flashes of bright light made it reminiscent of a conspiratorial show about UFOs.

So would this cause the public to think it was complete conspiracy?  Or is this type of presentation very seductive to some, making them change their minds about things they previously didn’t believe in, or were unaware of?

Can false sensationalism be successfully counteracted by “less false” sensationalism?

I would love to hear your opinion on this, as it has spurred new questions that I’m grappling with.  I will repost it, and hopefully initiate some discussion!  You don’t necessarily need to watch the whole thing – watching the first twenty minutes will give you an impression of the style used throughout.